Team-Based Learning online: percepção dos graduandos de saúde e influência do perfil comportamental do estudante / Online Team-Based Learning: perception of health undergraduates and influence of the student's behavioral profile

Resumo Introdução: O Team-Based Learning (TBL) é uma metodologia ativa que tem se mostrado efetiva para a formação de profissionais de saúde. Em 2020, devido à pandemia da Covid-19, a aplicação do TBL migrou da modalidade presencial para online síncrona. Objetivos: Este estudo objetivou avaliar a percepção de graduandos de saúde sobre o TBL online e analisar se existe diferença de percepção dessa modalidade entre os grupos de estudantes com níveis distintos de exposição anterior às sessões presenciais e online do método, além de verificar se tal percepção pode ser afetada pelo perfil comportamental do estudante. Método: Trata-se de um estudo observacional, transversal de caráter descritivo-exploratório, comparativo, relacional, de abordagem quantitativa, realizado nos cursos de graduação em Medicina e Enfermagem, entre setembro e dezembro de 2021. Aplicou-se, virtualmente, um questionário sobre os dados sociodemográficos, além dos instrumentos Avaliação da Percepção do Aluno-Team-Based Learning (APA-TBL) e Teste de Perfil Comportamental DISC. Resultados: Dos 241 estudantes participantes, houve predominância do sexo feminino (81%), na faixa etária de 20,8 a 24,4 anos, que já tinham frequentado mais de 10 sessões de TBL presencial (90%) e TBL online (53%). Das 24 questões do APA-TBL, 17 obtiveram índice igual ou superior a 75% na soma das respostas "concordo totalmente"/"concordo", valores considerados como percepção positiva neste estudo. Os alunos com exposição a mais de 10 sessões do TBL online apresentaram uma percepção significativamente mais negativa em três das quatro dimensões do APA-TBL, quando comparados aos menos expostos. O grupo que havia participado de mais de 10 sessões de TBL presencial apresentou uma percepção significativamente mais negativa em apenas uma dimensão do instrumento, quando comparados aos menos expostos. O principal fator DISC encontrado entre os perfis comportamentais dos participantes foi a estabilidade ("S"). Não houve correlação entre o perfil comportamental do aluno e sua percepção sobre o método na versão online. Conclusões: Observou-se uma percepção favorável dos graduandos de saúde sobre o TBL online. A exposição anterior prolongada ao método, tanto no modo online, quanto presencial, impactou negativamente a percepção dos estudantes sobre o TBL online. Não foi evidenciada influência do perfil comportamental do estudante em sua percepção do método.

Abstract Introduction: Team-Based Learning (TBL) is an active methodology that has shown to be effective for the training of health professionals. In 2020, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, TBL utilization migrated from the in-person to the synchronous online mode. Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the perception of health undergraduate students about online TBL and to analyze whether there is a difference regarding this perception between groups of students with different levels of exposure prior to in-person and online sessions of the teaching method, in addition to verifying whether such perception can be affected by the student's behavioral profile. Method: This is an observational, cross-sectional, descriptive-exploratory level II comparative study with a quantitative approach, carried out in undergraduate Nursing and Medicine courses between September and December 2021. A questionnaire on sociodemographic data was applied virtually, in addition to the Assessment of Student Perception-Team-Based Learning (ASP-TBL) and the DISC Personality Test instruments. Results: Of the 241 participating students, most were females (81%), aged between 20.8 and 24.4 years, who had already attended more than 10 sessions of in-person TBL (90%) and online TBL (53%). Of the 24 ASP-TBL questions, 17 obtained an index equal to or greater than 75% in the sum of the answers "I totally agree"/"I agree", values considered as a positive perception in this study. Students exposed to more than 10 online TBL sessions had a significantly more negative perception in three of the four dimensions of the ASP-TBL, when compared to less exposed students. The group that had participated in more than 10 in-person TBL sessions had a significantly more negative perception in only one dimension of the instrument, when compared to the less exposed ones. The main DISC Personality test factor found among the participants' behavioral profiles was submission ("S"). There was no correlation between the student's behavioral profile and their perception of the method in the online version. Conclusions: There was a favorable perception of health undergraduate students regarding online TBL. Previous prolonged exposure to the method, both online and in-person, represented a significant difference in the students' perception of online TBL. There was no evidence of the influence of the student's behavioral profile on their perception of the teaching method.

Application of outcome-based education combined with team-based learning in practice teaching of pediatric emergency and critical care nursing / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To investigate the application value of outcome-based education (OBE) combined with team-based learning (TBL) in the practice teaching of pediatric emergency and critical care nursing.Methods:A total of 84 nursing students who studied in the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) of The First Affiliated Hospital of Air Force Medical University were selected and divided into control group and observation group. The 41 nursing students in the control group received traditional teaching, and the 43 nursing students in the observation group received OBE+TBL teaching. The two groups were assessed in terms of theoretical knowledge, practical operation ability, clinical thinking ability, and self-learning ability after teaching, and the degrees of satisfaction with teaching and participation in teaching were compared between the two groups. SPSS 22.0 was used for the t-test and the chi-square test. Results:After teaching, the observation group had significantly better theoretical knowledge, practical operation ability, and self-learning ability than the control group ( P<0.05). Compared with the control group, the observation group had significantly higher scores of learning engagement (recognition, behavior, emotion) ( P<0.05) and satisfaction with classroom effect, knowledge mastery, and learning interest ( P<0.05). Conclusion:The application of OBE+TBL teaching in PICU nursing students can effectively improve their self-learning ability and participation and help them to understand PICU nursing priorities and improve their practical operation ability.

The application of improved team-based learning based on the training goal of excellent doctors in ophthalmology internship class / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To evaluate the effect of the improved team-based learning (TBL) teaching method in the undergraduate probation course of ophthalmology based on the goal of cultivating excellent doctors.Methods:The undergraduates of clinical medicine were randomly divided into experimental group and control group. The control group ( n=50) was given conventional ophthalmology probation teaching, while the experimental group ( n=50) was given ophthalmology probation teaching of improved TBL teaching method. The theoretical examination performance and skill assessment results of students in the two groups were compared, and the subjective evaluation of the students on the teaching was also compared. SPSS 23.0 was used to conduct t-test and Wilcoxon's rank sum test. Results:The theoretical examination performance of experimental group (29.68±4.52) was better than that of control group (27.84±4.33), with significant differences ( P<0.05); the skill assessment results of experimental group (32.88±5.05) were also better than those of the control group (30.88±6.99), with significant differences ( P<0.05); the subjective evaluation of teaching effect in each item of experimental group was better than that of control group ( P<0.05). Conclusion:The improved TBL teaching method can not only improve students' theoretical knowledge and experimental skills, but also improve students' self-study and teamwork ability, which will provide a feasible educational reform plan for achieving the goal of cultivating excellent doctors.

Application of the CBL combined with TBL based on SP teaching method in clinical teaching of department of intensive care medicine / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To study the teaching effect of the teaching method of case-based learning (CBL) combined with team-based learning (TBL) based on the standard patient (SP) in the clinical teaching of department of intensive care medicine.Methods:A total of 60 medical students clinically studying in the department of intensive care medicine were randomly divided into 2 groups, with 30 students in each group. The two groups received the clinical teaching through the lecture-based learning (LBL) teaching method and the CBL combined with TBL based on SP teaching method respectively. By evaluating the clinical synthesis ability of the students of two groups and the satisfaction survey of the two teaching methods, the teaching effect was evaluated. SPSS 19.0 statistical software was used to perform Chi-square test and t-test. Results:Compared with LBL teaching method, the students who accepted the CBL combined with TBL based on SP teaching method had significantly better clinical comprehensive ability ( P < 0.05), mainly in their clinical thinking ability [(4.18±0.55) vs. (3.66±0.47)], clinical skills [(4.03±0.61) vs. (3.59±0.52)] and communication ability with patients [(4.11±0.58) vs. (3.74±0.50)]. In addition, student satisfaction with teaching methods was also higher ( P <0.05), especially in the satisfaction of learning interest [(4.38 ± 0.72) vs. (3.65±0.56)], self-learning ability [(4.24±0.71) vs. (3.91±0.52)], clinical thinking ability [(4.09±0.66) vs. (3.22±0.54)], communication ability [(4.42±0.60) vs. (3.67±0.48)], and team cooperation spirit [(4.15±0.58) vs. (3.78±0.51)]. Conclusion:The teaching method of CBL combined with TBL based on SP is feasible and has good teaching effect in the clinical teaching of department of intensive care medicine.

Aprendizagem Baseada em Equipes no ensino remoto da promoção e educação em saúde na medicina / Team-based learning in remote teaching of health promotion and education at Medical School

Resumo: Introdução: A Aprendizagem Baseada em Equipes (ABE) é um método muito utilizado no ensino da promoção de saúde, pois instiga o exercício de habilidades como a liderança, o trabalho em equipe e a tomada de decisões. Com a pandemia da Covid-19, houve a necessidade de adaptar o ensino médico para o âmbito remoto. Assim, o objetivo deste artigo é descrever a experiência de adaptação de um componente curricular de Saúde Coletiva ao ambiente on-line, mantendo a ABE como método de ensino-aprendizagem da promoção de saúde, mesmo em tempos de pandemia. Relato de experiência: A aplicação do método foi feita por meio de videoconferências e de uma plataforma com recursos para a aplicação dos testes conforme o formato da ABE. Com os encontros, os estudantes desenvolveram competências essenciais à promoção da saúde, como salutogênese, metáforas da enfermidade na experiência do adoecimento, prevenção de agravos e educação em saúde. Discussão: A ABE consegue desenvolver no estudante habilidades como o trabalho em equipe, a liderança e o diálogo. Essas competências são preconizadas pelas Diretrizes Curriculares Nacionais durante a formação médica, além de serem essenciais na prática da promoção da saúde. Além disso, nota-se que o componente curricular promoveu uma construção salutogênica das capacidades dos alunos, desenvolvendo habilidades a partir das potencialidades dos estudantes, tal como em um grupo operativo. Ademais, a aplicação da ABE permitiu a continuidade do ensino de qualidade da promoção de saúde, mesmo em ambiente remoto, tendo em vista que essa metodologia estimula a aprendizagem ativa e oferece a possibilidade de aplicar os conhecimentos obtidos em situações práticas. As principais limitações da experiência foram as dificuldades de acesso às plataformas de ensino remoto, as restrições à comunicação não verbal e o controle sobre o acesso a materiais de consulta durante a execução de cada etapa. Conclusão: A adaptação da ABE ao ambiente remoto estimulou a prática de habilidades comunicativas e de argumentação que são essenciais à facilitação de grupos operativos na comunidade e permitiu que os estudantes aplicassem os conceitos aprendidos em situações práticas, apesar do ambiente remoto de ensino.

Abstract: Introduction: Team-Based Learning (TBL) is a method widely used in the teaching of health promotion as it instigates the exercise of skills such as leadership, teamwork and decision-making. With the emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a general need to adapt medical education to the remote environment. Thus, the objective of this article is to describe the experience of adapting a curricular component of Public Health to the online scenario, maintaining TBL as a teaching-learning methodology of health promotion, even during the pandemic. Experience Report: The method was applied through videoconferences and a platform with resources for the application of tests according to the TBL format. With the meetings, students developed essential skills about health promotion, such as salutogenesis, the illness metaphor during the process of getting sick, prevention and health education. Discussion: TBL develops students' skills such as teamwork, leadership and dialogue. These competencies are prescribed in the National Curricular Guidelines for undergraduate medical training, and are essential in the practice of health promotion. Furthermore, the discipline promoted a salutogenic construction of the students' capacities, developing skills based on their potential, just as in an operational group. Also, the application of TBL allowed the continued smooth teaching of health promotion despite the remote learning scenario, because this methodology encourages active learning and offers the possibility of applying the knowledge obtained in practical situations. The main limitations of the experience were difficulties encountered in accessing distance learning platforms, the limitations to non-verbal communication and the control over consultation materials during the execution of each stage. Conclusion: The adaptation of the TBL method to the remote scenario stimulated the practice of communicative and argumentative skills that are essential to the work with operative groups in the community and allowed students to apply the learned concepts in practical situations, despite the remote learning environment.

Comparación del rendimiento académico basado en metodología TBL y metodología tradicional de enseñanza en estudiantes de odontología en Santiago de Chile / Comparison of academic. Performance based on TBL methodology and traditional teaching methodology in dentistry students in Santiago de Chile

INTRODUCCION Con el pasar de los años han surgido metodologías activas de enseñanza, donde el estudiante pasa a tener un rol protagonista. La metodología activa Team Based Learning (TBL) promueve la participación de los estudiantes tanto de manera individual como grupal permitiendo fomentar el aprendizaje y aplicar contenidos enseñados. El objetivo de este estudio fue comparar el rendimiento académico obtenido por los estudiantes en la asignatura de cariología mediante metodología tradicional en los años 2016, 2017 y 2018; y metodología TBL en el año 2019. MATERIAL Y METODOS Se realizó un diseño analítico transversal donde se compararon los promedios de calificaciones de certámenes 1 y 2 de cariología de los estudiantes de la carrera de Odontología de la Universidad Finis Terrae entre los años 2016 y 2019; dicha población se estratificó en función de año académico y tipo de metodología. RESULTADOS Los resultados muestran que el promedio de las calificaciones de los certámenes 1 y 2 de cariología obtenido por los estudiantes mediante metodología tradicional de aprendizaje fue de 4,79 y mediante metodología TBL es de 5,01, existiendo una diferencia estadísticamente significativa entre ambos grupos de estudio (p = 0,03). CONCLUSION El rendimiento académico en cariología, obtenido por los estudiantes mediante metodología TBL el año 2019 fue significativamente mayor que aquel obtenido por los estudiantes mediante metodología tradicional en los años 2016, 2017 y 2018.

INTRODUCTION Over the years, active teaching methodologies have emerged, where the student play a leading role. The active Team Based Learning (TBL) methodology promotes participation of students both individually and in groups allowing to promote the learning and applying taught content. The aim of this study was to compare the academic performanc he students in the subject of cariology through traditional methodology in the years 2016, 2017 and 2018; and TBL methodology in 2019. MATERIAL AND METHODS A cross-sectional analytical design was conducted where the grade point of test 1 and 2 of cariology of Dentistry students from University Finis Terrae between the years 2016 and 2019, were averaged. The population was stratified according to academic year and type of methodology. RESULTS The results show that the average of the qualifications of test 1 and 2 of cariology obtained by students through traditional learning methodology was 4.79 and through TBL methodology is 5.01, there being a statistically significant difference between both study groups (p = 0.03). CONCLUSION The academic performance in cariology, obtained by the students through the TBL methodology on year 2019 was significantly higher than that obtained by the students through the methodology traditional in the years 2016, 2017 and 2018

Online Team-Based Learning in Teaching Hyponatremia Among Medical Clerks of the University of Santo Tomas Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, Philippines

@#<jats:p>Objectives: To determine if online team-based learning (TBL) is effective in improving knowledge outcomes and confidence about hyponatremia in its clinical recognition, classification, diagnostic work up, and management among fourth year medical students Study design: A quantitative evaluative design. Population and Setting: Fourth year medical students (medical clerks) rotating in the Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, University of Santo Tomas, Manila, Philippines from July to December 2020. Methodology: A modified TBL workshop is adopted in teaching fourth year medical clerks about hyponatremia. The TBL session was held with a group of medical clerks weekly from July to December 2020. As a pre-workshop preparation, the medical clerks were assigned to read ahead of time the clinical practice guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of hyponatremia developed by the European Renal Best Practice. After reading it, they were asked to answer an Individual Readiness Assessment Test (IRAT) composed of 20 case-based multiple-choice questions (MCQ). The group was thereafter divided into 4 subgroups and asked to discuss the same MCQ-based exam and present it as a Team Readiness Assessment Test (TRAT). As each subgroup presented their IRAT, the facilitator discussed the underlying concepts for each question and its application in actual cases of hyponatremia. The facilitator then summarized the learning outcomes at the end of the TBL workshop. For team application (TAPP), the students created a concept map and formulated admitting orders. The medical clerks were then surveyed on their confidence in hyponatremia diagnosis and management during pre-TBL workshop, after IRAT, after TRAT, and after discussion with the facilitator. Statistical Design: Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the study variables and included the mean, standard deviation, frequency, and percentage. Within-group comparisons of different outcomes across the different timeframes were conducted using one-way multivariate analysis of variance (one-way MANOVA). Cognizant that the study has multiple outcomes or dependent variables which were compared at four different timeframes, multivariate analysis was utilized to minimize the inflation of family-wise errors (FWE). Results: Comparative analysis indicated that the mean readiness scores of the respondents after TRAT was significantly higher (t=–91.61, p=0.001) compared to the mean readiness scores after IRAT. Comparative analysis using paired t-test indicated that the mean confidence scores of the respondents in the recognition, diagnosis, and treatment of hyponatremia were significantly higher among the respondents after the IRAT (t=–24.26, p=0.001), TRAT (t=–34.58, p=0.001), and facilitator discussion (t=–42.72, p=0.001) approaches compared to the mean pre-TBL confidence score. The mean knowledge score of the respondents on the creation of a concept map and the formulation of admission orders of patients with hyponatremia was 25.54±1.98 (95% CI 25.26-25.82). Conclusion: Findings of this study are not to be interpreted as demonstrating a causal relationship. Furthermore, the results are only hypothesis-generating at best. The study showed that online TBL has the potential to be an effective method in improving knowledge outcomes and confidence about hyponatremia in its clinical recognition, classification, diagnostic work-up, and management among fourth year medical students. As a preliminary evaluation of TBL, further studies can be conducted to determine its effectiveness as a teaching modality in the medical curricula in comparison to the traditional method before being adopted as a teaching-learning activity. Key words: team-based learning, online learning, COVID-19, hyponatremia, medical education</jats:p>

Effects of concept map combined with TBL teaching method on the examination results, critical thinking ability and teaching satisfaction of nursing interns / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To explore the effects of concept map combined with team-based learning (TBL) teaching method on the examination results, critical thinking ability and teaching satisfaction of nursing interns.Methods:A total of 67 nursing interns in Guangyuan Central Hospital from March to October 2019 were selected and randomly divided into study group and control group. TBL teaching method was used in the control group, and concept map combined with TBL teaching method was used in the study group. The assessment results, critical thinking ability and teaching satisfaction of the two groups were compared. SPSS 22.0 was used for chi-square test and t test. Results:The theoretical knowledge and final examination scores of the study group were higher than those of the control group ( P<0.05); after teaching, the scores of curiosity, truth seeking, systematic ability and self-confidence and total scores of the study group were higher than those before teaching and those of the control group ( P<0.05); the satisfaction scores on having great value to clinical practice, improving learning initiative, helping to understand teaching content, cultivating cooperative learning ability and stimulating learning competitiveness in the study group were higher than those in the control group ( P<0.05). Conclusion:Concept map combined with TBL teaching method is beneficial for nursing interns to master learning knowledge, improve critical thinking ability and increase teaching satisfaction.

Application of clinical pathway and team-based learning teaching method in standardized residency training of gynecology / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To explore the effectiveness of clinical pathway (CP) and team-based learning (TBL) teaching method in standardized residency training of gynecology.Methods:The research included 40 residents as objects who took standardized training in gynecological rotation in Luohe Central Hospital from July 2017 to July 2019, and they were randomized into experimental group and control group. The combination of CP and TBL teaching method was used in the experimental group ( n=20), while the traditional teaching method was applied in the control group ( n=20). All residents were tested for the professional theory and clinical skill after training. After the training, a survey about the teaching satisfaction and the effectiveness of teaching methods was conducted for both groups. Statistical analysis was performed by SPSS 23.0 software. Results:The average scores of professional theory and clinical practice skills in the experimental group were (85.55±5.96) points and (89.90±6.40) points respectively, which were better than the average scores of the control group [(76.36±6.68) points and (75.50±4.81) points, respectively], and there were significant differences between two groups ( P<0.05). The results of the questionnaire survey showed that the experimental group residents had a higher degree of satisfaction and a higher evaluation of the teaching method than the control group. Conclusion:CP and TBL teaching is beneficial to improve the quality of standardized residency training of gynecology, and it is suggested to make wide popularization and application in the training.

Practical application of SP-assisted PBL combined with TBL mode in pediatric first aid teaching / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To analyze and discuss the application value and teaching effect of simulate patients (SP)-assisted problem-based learning (PBL) combined with team-based learning (TBL) mode in pediatric first aid teaching, in order to provide a new reference for the reform of standardized residency training and teaching mode of pediatrics in the new era in China.Methods:A total of 103 residents who participated in the standardized training in the Department of Pediatrics of Hunan Children's Hospital from January 2018 to December 2020 were selected as the research objects, and they were divided into the control group (50 cases) and the experimental group (53 cases). The control group adopted the previous teaching mode of residents, while the experimental group adopted the SP-assisted PBL combined with TBL mode. In this study, SPSS 22.0 software was used for t test and chi-square test. Results:The examination scores of the experimental group in the theoretical knowledge of pediatric first aid, clinical thinking and skills, and application of pediatric first aid skills were higher than those in the control group [(86.98±3.42), (85.69±5.13), (89.62±4.75)] vs. [(77.23±4.16), (81.16±3.96), (76.54±5.78)], with statistically significant differences between the two groups ( P<0.05). The questionnaire survey showed that the clinical thinking and pediatric emergency skills, doctor-patient communication ability, teamwork ability and other aspects of the experimental group were significantly better than those of the control group ( P<0.05). Conclusion:The SP-assisted PBL combined with TBL mode can produce positive effects in the standardized residency training of pediatrics, which will help residents better master pediatric first aid skills, improve their clinical comprehensive capabilities, and be more conducive to improving the quality of pediatric residency training, which is worth promoting in the new era.

Evaluating the effect of flipped classroom combined with TBL by DOPS in clinical practice teaching for interns in ophthalmology / 国际眼科杂志(Guoji Yanke Zazhi)

AIM: To explore the effect of flipped classroom combined with team-based learning(TBL)in ophthalmology practice teaching by applying directly observed procedural skills(DOPS). METHODS: A total of 54 students of clinical medicine “5+3” integration and clinical medicine for five years, interned at the department of ophthalmology from June 15th to November 14th, 2021 were divided into traditional teaching group(group A)and flipped classroom combined with TBL group(group B). The teaching effects of slit lamp microscopy and direct ophthalmoscopy in group A and group B were compared by DOPS score, and Mann-Whitney U test was used for statistical analysis.RESULTS: Total DOPS score for slit-lamp microscopy in group A was 59(58.00, 60.00)points,which was significantly lower than that of group B 63(61.00,65.00)points(P&#x003C;0.001). The DOPS score for direct ophthalmoscopy in group A was 63(61.00, 63.75)points, which was significantly lower than that of group B, 66(63.75,66.25)points(P&#x003C;0.001). In the two operations and especially in the aspects of “understanding of complications,relevant anatomical structure and proficiency in operation”“preparatory work” and “technical ability of operation”, the scores of group B was significantly higher than those of group A(P&#x003C;0.05).CONCLUSION: Flipped classroom combined with TBL has significant advantages in clinical practice teaching for interns in ophthalmology, which is worthy of promotion and application compared with traditional teaching.

Guerra de clanes: aprendizaje basado en equipos como estrategia digital de enseñanza y evaluación a distancia en ciencias morfológicas / Clan war: team-based learning as a digital distance teaching and assessment strategy in morphological sciences

RESUMEN: Debido a la creciente demanda de recursos digitales en la enseñanza y evaluación en morfología, se ha planteado el desafío de evaluar adecuadamente los resultados de aprendizaje adquiridos, la realización de evaluaciones tradicionales en formato digital no es un instrumento adecuado para medir los niveles de aprendizaje adquiridos, lo que hace necesario desarrollar estrategias de enseñanza y evaluación que nos permitan evidenciar de mejor manera lo que los estudiantes aprenden en este formato. En el presente trabajo entregamos una estrategia de aprendizaje basado en equipos, en los cuales se potencia el sentido lúdico, el trabajo en equipo, la motivación, en conjunto con actividades que permiten que los estudiantes demuestren que se desenvuelven en los niveles más complejos del aprendizaje.

SUMMARY: Due to the growing demand for digital resources in teaching and evaluation in morphology, it is necessary to adequately evaluate the learning outcomes acquired. The realization of traditional evaluations in digital format is not an adequate instrument to measure the acquired learning levels. In the present work we show a team-based learning strategy, in which the sense of play, teamwork, and motivation are enhanced, along with activities that allow students to demonstrate that they function in the most complex levels of learning.

The Outcomes of Team-based Learning on Test Performance, Cognitive Engagement and Motivation in Preclinical Anatomy Practical Classes

@#Introduction: Designing an engaging teaching strategy that enhances the clinical application of anatomy knowledge is important for effective learning. Hence, this study was carried out to evaluate the outcomes of team-based learning (TBL) approach on students’ learning during gross anatomy practical classes. Method: A randomised-controlled trial was conducted on 215 pre-clinical year medical students, who were divided into TBL and control groups. Both groups attended the same anatomy lecture before the practical session. The TBL group underwent three phases of activities, which were pre-practical assignment (Phase-1), individual and team readiness assurance tests followed by a debriefing session (Phase-2), and group application task (Phase-3). Concurrently, the control group received a reading material as their pre-practical assignment and attended a practical session in the form of an anatomy model demonstration. Pre- and post-practical assessments were measured 30 minutes before and after the practical sessions. The students’ cognitive engagement and motivation were also measured after the practical sessions. Results: The TBL group among the Year-1 students outperformed the control group in all the test performance measures. The TBL group of the Year-1 students was also found to have greater improvement of test scores compared to their control counterparts. The TBL group was found to have significantly higher cognitive engagement scores only among the Year-2 students. However, the internal motivation scores were not significant in both cohorts. Conclusion: These results indicate that the TBL session contributes positive outcomes to students’ learning in anatomy context.

Effectiveness of TBL+ CBD method applied in the course teaching of Introduction to General Practice / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To verify the application value of team-based learning (TBL) joint case-based discussion (CBD) method applied in the course teaching of Introduction to General Practice.Methods:Students from two clinical oriented classes in the same grade were divided into the experimental group ( n=35) and the control group ( n=35). The control group implemented the traditional teaching method, and the experimental group implemented the TBL joint CBD method. The teaching effect were compared between the two groups. SPSS 20.0 was used for frequency description and statistical test analysis. Non-normal distribution data were tested with Mann-Whitney U test. Results:After the teaching, the average rank of multiple-choice questions (35.28) and analytic questions (42.24) in the experimental group were significantly higher than those of the control group (32.68 and 25.52, respectively, P<0.05). Conclusion:The TBL joint CBD method applied in the course of general practice helps to improve students' test achievement, enhance their overall quality, and lay a foundation for training comprehensive competencies of general practitioners.

Working Group Report (Practice article 2) : Online Interprofessional Education Stepwise Interprofessional Education through Inter-University Collaboration at the University of Tsukuba (1) / 医学教育

For this second report, we divided the efforts of the University of Tsukuba into two parts. In the first part, we introduced the Interprofessional program, an inter-university collaborative educational program between the University of Tsukuba and Ibaraki Prefectural University of Health Sciences. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, this program was conducted using TBL (Team-based learning) in a large conference room. After the pandemic, this was conducted online (using Zoom). The main changes due to the online implementation were the following five points; (1) online faculty meetings, (2) advance distribution of materials, (3) testing using Google Forms, (4) group work using the breakout function, and (5) simultaneous editing using Google Docs. In the future, we would like to examine the possibility of new educational methods while creating innovations that are possible only through online interprofessional educational programs.

Application of TBL teaching method based on digital slices in the teaching of pathology of oral mucosal disease / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To construct a teaching model of pathology of oral mucosal disease through team-based learning (TBL) based on digital slices combined with mind mapping, and to explore its teaching effect.Methods:A total of 64 oral medical five-year undergraduates from Batch 2017 who took oral histology and pathology were randomized into 2 groups in average, experimental group and control group. Both groups were asked to do self-study on line before class. Students in the experimental group were taught by TBL method. While students in the control group were taught by the traditional methods. Effects of the different teaching methods were evaluated by comparing the scores of two groups. Besides, questionnaires on teaching effect were distributed to evaluate students' satisfaction with TBL method, with Likert 5 as the guideline for scoring. SPSS 2016 was used to analyze the data.Results:The experimental group achieved better teaching results than the control group did, and the students were more satisfied with TBL method.Conclusion:It can be concluded from the study that, the teaching mode of TBL method combined with mind mapping can cause better teaching effects and improve the students' clinical thinking ability and teamwork ability, which is worthy of wide application.

Retos de la implementación del aprendizaje basado en equipos en los programas de medicina / The challenges of implementing team-based learning to the medical major programs

Introducción: El aprendizaje basado en equipos es una estrategia de enseñanza y de aprendizaje centrada en el alumno, en la cual el profesor tiene un rol facilitador. Este constituye un método pedagógico de aprendizaje activo que mejora la motivación hacia el aprendizaje y lleva a los alumnos a aplicar sus conocimientos para resolver problemas y combinar la teoría con la práctica. Los avances en educación médica a nivel mundial han llevado a las escuelas de medicina a optar por este tipo de estrategias. Objetivo: Identificar los retos de la implementación del aprendizaje basado en equipos en los programas de medicina. Resultados: Mediante la aplicación del aprendizaje basado en equipos en los programas de medicina, se identificaron los factores de sobrecarga laboral y de estudio con incidencia en los participantes en la estrategia, la necesidad de garantizar entrenamiento previo a los actores del proceso, la importancia de la realización de una adecuada distribución de los grupos de trabajo, y los recursos adicionales que deben garantizarse. Conclusiones: Para obtener beneficios pedagógicos de forma plena, la implementación del aprendizaje basado en equipos debe ser sistemática, lo que requiere procesos de formación y preparación, tanto de los estudiantes como de los profesores. Como cualquier cambio, demandará convicción, tiempo y ajustes a lo largo del proceso(AU)

Introduction: Team-based learning is a student-centered teaching and learning strategy, in which the teacher has the role of a facilitator. It constitutes an active learning pedagogical method that improves motivation towards learning and leads students to apply their knowledge to solve problems and combine theory with practice. Advances in medical education worldwide have led medical schools to opt for such strategies. Objective: To identify the challenges of implementing team-based learning in the medical major programs. Results: Through the application of team-based learning to the medical major programs, such factors as work and study overloads were identified as having an impact on the strategy participants, together with the need to guarantee prior training to the process stakeholders, the importance of adequate distribution of the working groups, and the additional resources that must be guaranteed. Conclusions: In order to obtain full pedagogical benefits, the implementation of team-based learning must be systematic, a process requiring training and preparation processes for both students and teachers. Like any change, it will demand conviction, time and adjustments throughout the process(AU)

Percepção de Alunos de Curso de Graduação em Medicina sobre o Team-Based Learning (TBL) / Undergraduate Medical Students' Views on Team-Based Learning (TBL)

RESUMO O Team-Based Learning (TBL) é uma estratégia educacional baseada em aprendizagem ativa que se tornou uma proposta pedagógica alternativa importante no contexto dos métodos de ensino utilizados em educação médica. A proposta do presente trabalho foi avaliar a percepção dos alunos sobre o uso da metodologia TBL em curso de graduação em Medicina e analisar os diferentes aspectos da aplicação desse método de ensino em relação à forma tradicional de ensino utilizada na maior parte dos cursos de Medicina no País. Foi aplicado um questionário específico aos alunos com oito questões e respostas dicotomizadas (escala de Likert com cinco itens). Durante o mês de junho de 2017, alunos do curso de graduação em Medicina (quarto e sétimo períodos) foram submetidos a várias sessões de ensino com o método TBL na Universidade Municipal de São Caetano do Sul (USCS) com os temas sepse, trauma, leucemia, câncer colorretal e câncer de pulmão. A amostra foi calculada em 193 participantes, considerando uma precisão relativa de 10% e um nível de significância de 5% para uma estimativa de 70% de respostas positivas (concordo e concordo firmemente) para a afirmação "Esse TBL teve um impacto positivo no meu aprendizado". A análise foi realizada com cálculo de estatística descritiva e das frequências relativas e absolutas de respostas com intervalo de confiança de 95% para cada ponto estimado. A utilização do método foi percebida como favorável nos aspectos de preferência (em relação à aula expositiva tradicional), motivação, satisfação e aprendizado. O TBL se destacou como um método pedagógico excelente para a aprendizagem em alunos do curso de Medicina. Uma das vantagens foi a capacidade de desenvolver habilidades em raciocínio clínico e a possibilidade de construir o conhecimento com sua utilização prática. O método ativo apareceu, dessa forma, como uma importante alternativa de metodologia se comparada ao método tradicional.

ABSTRACT Team-Based Learning (TBL) is an educational strategy based on active learning which has become an important alternative pedagogical proposal in the context of teaching methods used in medical education. The aim of this study was to evaluate students' perceptions about the use of the TBL methodology in Medical School and to analyze the different aspects of the application of this teaching method. A specific questionnaire was applied to the students with 8 questions and dichotomized answers (Likert scale with 5 items). During the month of June 2017 second and fourth year undergraduate medical students underwent several sessions of teaching with the TBL method at the Municipal University of São Caetano do Sul (USCS) with focus on the following themes: sepsis; trauma; leukemia; colorectal cancer; and lung cancer. The sample was calculated on 193 participants considering a relative precision of 10% and a statistical significance of 5% for an estimate of 70% of positive responses (strongly agree and agree) to the statement "This TBL had a positive impact on my learning". The analysis was performed with descriptive statistics and the relative and absolute frequencies of responses with a 95% confidence interval for each estimated point. The use of the method was perceived as positive in aspects of preference (regarding the traditional expository class), motivation, satisfaction and learning. TBL stood out as an excellent pedagogical method for learning among medical students. One of the advantages was the ability to develop skills in clinical reasoning and the possibility of building knowledge with its practical use. The active method was thus found to be an important methodological alternative when compared to the traditional method.

Application of TBL Teaching Model in the Course of Pharmaceutical Ethics / 中国医学伦理学

Objective:To explore the application of Team-Based Learning (TBL) in the course of pharmaceutical medical ethics, thus to provide references for further improvement of teaching effect. Methods: In the course of teaching, the TBL teaching model was adopted, and the investigation and feedback was carried out at the end of the course. Results:The application of TBL teaching mode had certain advantages in pharmaceutical medical ethics, which not only arouse the enthusiasm of students' autonomous learning, and cultivate the ability of discovering, analyzing, solving problems and the spirit of teamwork, so as to cultivate the humanistic spirit of pharmacy, but also stimulate the teachers' enthusiasm for work.Conclusion: As a supplement and optimization of the existing teaching methods, the TBL teaching model is worth promoting, but some possible ways should be taken to remedy deficiencies, rationally grouping and motivate students' interests in learning.

The Satisfaction of Team-Based Learning on Discussion in the Training Course of Emergency Medical Technician / 의료커뮤니케이션

BACKGROUND: Team-based learning is known for its effective and satisfying education methods in the study of various medical schools. This study was prepared to confirm the satisfaction of applying this team-based learning to the training course of emergency medical technician.METHODS: A total of 165 new members of the course of second grade National Emergency medical technician at 2019 were finally enrolled in the study. Data were collected with a self-administered questionnaire. The team-based learning method was organized with eight students per group to conduct pre-learning and then proceed to open book to encourage active discussion among individuals. The questionnaire consisted of questions about the satisfaction of the discussion process, such as whether the knowledge gained from the discussion was appropriate, and whether collaboration between colleagues was successful during the discussion, and about the benefits of team-based learning, how well knowledge transfer compared to existing lectures, and the replacement of existing lectures. The questionnaire used a Likert 5 point scale, and the data obtained were analyzed using the SPSS version 22.0.RESULTS: The overall rating of team-based learning was 7.8 ± 1.5 out of 10. Many students answered positively (88.5%) for benefits, while 87.9% responded positively to whether the knowledge transfer effect was better compared to existing lectures. In addition, the satisfaction of team-based learning was generally high, with more than 90 percent of education students giving positive answers to the replacement of other lectures with team-based learning.CONCLUSION: The learners gave positive answers to the satisfaction, usefulness and learning effects of team-based learning. Team-based learning is a discussion-based study, so it is a good way to improve communication skills. Since communication and teamwork are important in first aid activities, the characteristics of team-based learning could lead to improvements in first aid services, leading to high-quality emergency medical services.